In the fearful aftermath of 9/11, multi-award-winning, Jewish community leader Nancy Kaufman found herself at the epicenter of a local interfaith battle in Boston, facing overwhelming pressure from major donors and fearful groups in her own Jewish community to actively block the construction of a new Muslim mosque. The default assumption and interpretation was that the mosque was that the mosque would be a hotbed of anti-Semitism.
This moment demanded bold, adaptive leadership and extraordinary interfaith courage. Kaufman’s decision to risk her career and reputation and quietly build bridges of truth became a seven-year test of integrity and resolve. Her story is a powerful testament to the power of “Playing the Long Game.”
Discover how she battled internal threats, external forces, and accusations of betrayal to maintain her values. Importantly, learn the enduring lessons she gleaned from Nelson Mandela on building coalitions and working with the opposition, which ultimately led to the unexpected realization that your fiercest foe may become your greatest ally. This episode culminates in an unforgettable moment of powerful unity—when Kaufman was asked to offer the closing prayer at the dedication in the very mosque she had once been pressured to stop being built.
—
Listen to the podcast here
“Play the Long Game” with Nancy Kaufman in NYC, US
Adaptive Leadership, Interfaith Courage, and Why Your Fiercest Foe May Become Your Greatest Ally
They asked her to stop the building of a mosque. Instead, seven years on, she gave the closing prayer inside it. What happens when fear is weaponized and a bold Jewish woman chooses truth, time, courage, and conviction despite monumental pressure and threats? Greetings to all you future bold leaders. Thank you for joining us from around the world.
Our thoughtful, bold leader joins us from the Big Apple in New York City in the United States. Let’s take a trip back in time. Post 9/11, in the early 2000s, two large commercial jets flew straight into the Twin Towers in New York City. The world declares war on terror. Islamophobia and fear are weaponized. Back in Boston, where she lived and worked at the time as the Executive Director of the Boston Jewish Community Relations Council, wealthy Jewish donors called on her to stop the building of a Muslim mosque.
The pressure is enormous. The stakes are career-defining. She doesn’t stop it. Instead, she challenges the narrative, tells the truth about the quality of relationships, the interfaith relationships, and mobilizes the system. We talk to that woman, a four-time award-winning, Future 50 Outstanding Jewish Leader Award recipient, an Executive Coach, the former CEO of the National Council of Jewish Women, and a fearless leader who spent twenty years as the executive director of the Boston Jewish Community Relations Council, an umbrella organization of 42 organizations, where she led transformational initiatives with other interfaith leaders in the inner city of Boston and beyond.
Stay tuned as she shares remarkable insights into adaptive leadership, including what it took to build the mosque and to deliver her magnificent closing prayer to more than 1,000 worshipers; some of the inner-city initiatives between violent gangs and Boston churches; and her inspiring trip to South Africa with Nelson Mandela whispering in her ear every step of the way. This is a conversation about adaptive leadership, not in the classroom, but in a Boston interfaith firestorm. We warmly welcome my larger-than-life, warm-hearted friend, Nancy Kaufman, and welcome to the show.

Nancy, welcome. It is so wonderful to see you again. Thank you for joining us.
Thank you for having me.
A wonderful place to begin. You are a woman with a remarkable career, leadership lessons, and a legacy. Can you describe that moment?
Yes, I can. I go back to a moment, probably in the early 2000s, soon after 9/11, when everyone was hysterical and fearful about what the world was going to look like. I was in Boston at the time as the Executive Director of the Jewish Community Relations Council, an umbrella organization for 42 different organizations that does extensive intergroup and social policy work. I take us back to that time. The environment is one of a very changed environment, one from one that was all about interrelating, intergroup, working across lines of difference, to one where the Jewish community at that time felt very vulnerable.
Jewish Donors Demanded She Stop The Mosque
I felt like it was more of an opportunity than ever before to build bridges to people different from us, particularly in the Muslim community, but beyond that. I saw the beginnings of the Islamophobia that was developing. I had worked for 10 years very closely in the African-American community in Boston and had many relationships across diverse communities. A gentleman whom I knew, a major donor to the Jewish community, comes up to me as I am going into my office and says, “Nancy, what are you doing to stop the mosque from being built in Boston?”
I went, “Excuse me.” “Nancy, what are you doing to stop the mosque from being built in Boston? You are supposed to be securing the Jewish community, defending the Jewish community. It’s going to be a Wahhabi fundamentalist mosque, and we need to stop it.” I was dumbfounded. It was like, “What are you talking about?” I knew that the city had given land to a small Islamic Society of Boston, and that they planned to build a very large mosque in the inner city. I was like, “Where is this coming from?”
I went back to the office, and soon after, I started getting calls from people on the right side of the ledger saying the same thing. I called a meeting in my office of some key people, including the organization that was leading the charge to stop the mosque from being built in Boston. I decided you sometimes need to go right to the enemy, in this case, the one that is challenging on the other side. I brought with me two very senior individuals from the Jewish community, the head of the American Jewish Committee and the head of the Anti-Defamation League.
I said, “Tell us why you think there’s going to be this. Why is this a problem?” They needed to tell us that they had developed an ad hoc committee to stop the mosque from being built. They proceeded to tell us in detail that they had found a rebuttal to the property to sue the city of Boston for giving them the land for the mosque, and went on about why this was going to be an anti-Semitic Wahhabi mosque in Boston. This went on for a little while. I said, “What makes you think that?”
We knew the people behind the mosque’s construction, and they had a small storefront in Cambridge, Massachusetts. This gentleman, who was leading the charge, said, “They preach anti-Semitism in their mosque, and they have anti-Semitic literature in their library.” One of my colleagues turned purple. He is a very quiet guy. He stood up, and he started screaming, “What are you talking about?
Have you ever been to the mosque in Cambridge?” This gentleman said, “No, but that’s what I understand.” Really. Now we are talking about hearsay and fake news. I said, “They don’t have a library. They have a bookshelf. What are you talking about? You don’t know what you’re talking about.” Anyway, we knew that this was going to become a very large issue in the community because they had major donors behind them. What did/do I do? I was this person, the point person for the Jewish community.
In terms of what you did, was there an a-ha moment? Was there a realization?
There was a big aha moment. The big a-ha moment was that we were going to have to build support for a counter conversation and that it was not going to be easy. It was not easy because of the pressures that were being brought to bear, because it was being stoked by fear, which, of course, this hatred is usually stoked by fear. We were being stoked by fear. It got worse.
There was a series of things that happened, including a press conference that this Jewish group held and attacked, literally verbally attacking the chair of the (mosque) board, who was a psychiatrist, saying that he was a member of the Muslim Brotherhood. Only the Boston Herald and Fox News covered it, and the Islamic Society of Boston then sued the group that was doing this for defamation. It is a very long, complicated story that I do not have time to tell all about my role in it.
What I felt was that my responsibility was to tell the truth. I am literally sitting in a hotel in Ukraine, where we had a partnership with the key leaders of Boston’s Jewish community. I get a call from my office, from my deputy, who says, “We’re being asked to comment on the lawsuit and to defend the organization that is suing the Muslims.” I went, “What? What are you talking about?” They say, “Yes, so-and-so called, and they are telling us we must publicly defend this Jewish group.” I turned around.
You’re conflicted at this point.
Refusing To Compromise Integrity In The Lawsuit – Competing Commitments
I am very conflicted. I am in a horrible situation because I am under enormous pressure to basically cave and say, “Yes, it’s all true.” I know that it is not all true. I actually know that it is not all true. I turn around and look at the chair of my board, the chair of the Federation board, some very important people, and there is this lawsuit now, and they said we should, (and they all look at me, and they say), “We should say that they are being sued for asking questions.”
I went, “Excuse me, where are the questions?” I said, “We weigh in on this. I don’t want to get deposed, because if I get deposed in the lawsuit, I will tell the truth.” That is what I said. It went on for many months, if not years. What did I do? What I did was try to provide good leadership, not public leadership, but private leadership, quietly to go around and build support in the community so that the people understood what was happening here.
If you take us through the steps of how you pivoted out of that, were there specific stakeholders you identified in groups within the community? Can you share a few of those actions with us?
Yes, yes. I did a number of things. I met one-on-one with major community leaders who really did not know what was going on. You understand most of this was under the radar screen, and anytime that it became over the radar screen, I would get into trouble for making it a public issue. My job was threatened, I was threatened, but not by my board. My board was supporting me. Yes, I went around and had one-on-one conversations.
I also got Harvard University involved and got the Kennedy School and the Divinity School that had gotten a large grant to take this up as a case study for us to have a conference about it and to have an invitational symposium with 25 Jewish leaders, 25 Muslim leaders, and 25 Christian leaders to come together to discuss the situation and how we as leaders could navigate it. That ended up blowing up. We regrouped because we had decided to invite a major speaker from each core group.
A major Christian national speaker, a major Muslim, and a major Jewish speaker. I was again sitting in Israel on a trip with colleagues when I got a call three weeks before this conference was scheduled to take place in Cambridge, Massachusetts. We had the Jewish, Muslim, and Christian speakers. They were all approved by everyone.
We had a committee that was working on this. I put a lot of energy into this. At the last minute, the Jewish speaker, a nationally known rabbi, pulled out. Why did he pull out? The Muslim speaker who had been approved by everyone could not do it. We went to the Dean of the Harvard Divinity School, who was not Muslim but was an Islamic scholar, and asked him to recommend someone. He recommended someone from Los Angeles who had been his PhD student at Harvard Divinity School.
When that happened, we said, “That sounds good.” He was not approved by everybody. I came back with the dilemma. Now what do we do? Three weeks before this announced conference, the Jewish speaker had pulled out. The Muslim speaker is not approved. Many of the participants pulled out. I basically told the interfaith committee the truth privately.
I said, “This is what I’m up against. This is our problem. What do we do?” We decided as a group that all we could do was postpone the conference because we could not be in a position where we were being uninviting, vetoing, or censoring a speaker. We decided to postpone it until the fall. We decided that, rather than have a speaker representing everybody, we would not have those three speakers.
We would simply have the Deans of the Divinity School and the Kennedy School, and we would do the work together in groups. There was a lot of pivoting and a lot of different things. I did an education series. I did everything in my power to get, in my case, the Jewish community to see this in a broader way and not from a place of fear, and to preserve the relationships we had built because clearly the Muslim community was not happy. We got through it.
What was the outcome?
The outcome was that I was pressing very hard for mediation, but the Jewish groups would not pursue it. After a long time, the lawsuit was dropped because it was completely ridiculous. It dissipated because people lost interest. I am happy to say that the mosque was built. On the day that I accepted my new job in New York as CEO of the National Council of Jewish Women, I went to the mosque for the first time, which was a $20 million mosque.
I had not gone there because the minute I went there, I would have been lambasted by the press, but my staff had been very involved. I walked in, and everyone came up and said, “We’re so glad you are here. Will you give the closing prayer?” I said, “I absolutely would be delighted.” It is now a beautiful mosque in the city of Boston, and Jews and Muslims come together, and the person who led all this after several years was discredited and marginalized, but it took a long time, and it was very painful.
That is an incredible story. For you, Nancy, what were the big lessons, and how did you feel once you reached that outcome? Saying the closing prayer in the mosque, how did you feel, and what were the big leadership realizations for you?
The Long Game Requires Staying The Course Despite Threats
The big realization, as I said to a leadership seminar that I taught at Brandeis several years ago, was that I fought the fight, I fought the battle, I lost the war, but I lost with my integrity intact. In other words, it went on for too long.

How long was too long?
Probably five (to seven) years. It was a long time. It took a lot of energy from me because I was constantly having to deal with threats against me, against my job, and against my money. It was enormous. It really felt McCarthy-esque, to be honest with you. It was unbelievable things being said, and it really challenged my integrity. My commitment was not to walk away. I waited until it was all resolved, and when it was finally, I was exhausted. I realized it was time to move on.
At that point, the mosque was built. What I learned from this is that, first of all, there are situations. Again, Mandela is an inspiration for this; things do not get resolved in weeks, months, or even years. Sometimes it takes just hanging in, staying in, staying the course, and knowing you are right. Always willing to walk out if you have to. I always had in the back of my mind that if I were asked to compromise my values and integrity, then that is when I would have to resign.
When you say “walk out,” don’t mean walking away from navigating the issue; be willing to stand up for your values and principles.
That is right. I was very clear, and I built support around me. I tried to build circles of support of different allies in the community, which got me into trouble at different points. I was accused, at one point, by one of the major donors involved in this. His wife had been involved in feminist and women’s work. I asked her if she would like to meet some Muslim women, and I would love to put that together. The next thing I know, I got a call saying that her husband had threatened that I was trying to destroy their marriage. I got a call from my funder saying, “Nancy, what are you doing? I understand you’re trying to destroy their marriage.” I went, “What?” I said, “I simply suggested that she meet with some Muslim women.” It was really brutal what went on.
The leadership lesson is (I am pleased you mentioned how long these things take), when you said ‘it went on too long,’ I guess part of the learning is that these things do take a long time.
The learning there, and most of the other situations that I have been in that have been challenging leadership situations, is that you have to be willing to stay the course. You have to be strong enough to have a real belief in your convictions that you are right and a willingness to take whatever consequences that would mean. This was a very big deal. It is something I still want to write a case study about, but there was the whole New York mosque situation around 9/11 that was so public. This was much bigger than that, because it was not just a matter of “Where is it located?” That was it, that it should not exist at all because it is going to be this thing. I was told, “You must stop this because they’re coming to kill our children.”
You have to believe in your convictions strongly enough to accept whatever consequences come with standing by them.
That is what I was told by people.
I explained that suburban Jewish children in Boston were not the ones who would be most at risk, if God forbid, there was a Wahhabi fundamentalist mosque in the center of the city of Boston. I was quite stunned by the conflict. I did all kinds of things. I met with all kinds of groups. I pushed people to speak out, even if I could not speak out, to get other people to speak out, so that there would be a force against the force that was very powerful.
That moment of saying the prayer in the mosque, what did that mean to you? How did you feel?
It was an incredible moment. There were about a thousand people there; it was last-minute. I did not have time to think, but what popped into my head was Isaiah 58, which is the prayer that is really around Yom Kippur. My choice of prayer said: ‘free those enslaved, to help the homeless, to feed the hungry.’ This is the fast I chose. I belted it out, and everyone cheered and clapped at the end. I just did it because I felt like I could breathe, I could be who I am. I strongly felt, which is why I was so happy to be asked to do this, that my Jewish values were what were guiding me through the whole thing, and that I was able to express that. It was a very nice thing. I did not care if it was on the front page of the Jewish newspaper in the morning or not because I was leaving.
Out of interest, how did the Jewish community feel?
There were many different Jewish communities. My immediate community was thrilled because that is what they wanted me to be doing. My staff, my board, they were supporting me. They were very supportive. The broader community at that point did not care anymore. They had moved on because the mosque was built, and clearly it was not a Wahhabi fundamental mosque. What is so sad about some of these situations is that people get all fired up, and then they move on to the next thing.
There is a lesson in that, too, is there not?
Yes, because sometimes the opposition. I hope that is the lesson that the Trump movement in this country will be experiencing, which is that it is going to peter out, I deeply hope. Basically, that is what happened. It petered out over several years, probably more than five years, from beginning to end. The major protagonist in this, who was pretty much a right-winger and a Republican, has become the opposite. It is just so ironic to me now that he is funding the organization I once led and that he wanted to destroy. Change does happen.
People shift their loyalties, too. How did that experience, that moment, shape your life decisions and your leadership decisions going forward? How do you think that moment shaped you?
It shaped me in many ways. It made me really want to work towards something positive and possible and lead the community towards that, which is why, when I moved to head up the National Council of Jewish Women, a progressive Jewish feminist organization, there was much greater positivity. It was a wonderful alignment. It was much harder when I did this work. It made me realize that we have all this energy and that sometimes using our energy can be so negative, and you can either use positive energy or negative energy.
We all have energy, but how we use it matters. It can build or destroy—positive or negative, the choice is ours.
That is, again, another Mandela inspiration that I have gotten, certainly from reading his autobiography and from being in South Africa and walking the steps from Johannesburg to the prison and to Cape Town. Here is a man who just stayed the course. He just continued to see the goalpost and continued working towards the goal that he had, and did not let the turkeys get him down. He just said, “That’s their problem.” When he came out, he was willing to make a partner of the enemy, which is so brilliant and amazing. The inspiration for me was that change takes time, that it is possible, and that if you have allies and you have inner resolve and strength, you can make very big changes in the world.
That is such a powerful thing. You have kind of opened the Mandela (Madiba) door. Do you have a particular Mandela Moment? I know Mandela has inspired you on many different occasions. Is there an occasion, a specific moment, where he struck a chord, he lit a fire? Can you share a moment? Where were you? What was the situation?
I probably have two big ones. The first was back in Boston. He came to Boston in June of 1990. It was exactly at the end of my tenure in government, when I was going to be transferred.
That was just after he was released, in 1990.
He was released in February. He was on his tour of America to raise money for the ANC. I was there, and I was like, “Oh my God.”
Where exactly were you?
Mandela Inspired The Pivot To Inner City Bridge Building
At Boston Common, he gave his speech, and there were probably 10,000 people there. Soon after that, I was hired to be in the Jewish community and run this big umbrella. One of the first things I committed myself to, and it was all coming out of, this is my big early Mandela Moment, was bridging the gap between the largely suburban Jewish white community and its inner city roots in the African-American community. The feeling among Jews at that point was that there was all this anti-Semitism, and they did not want us involved. We were asked to take a walk, and we ended up taking a hike. No Jews were living in the city anymore. You had this very large and, at that time, very crime-ridden inner city.
That was a dark moment.
A very dark moment. It was a time when there was enormous violence in the streets of Boston, so there was a lot of fear. I was really committed to finding partners who would help me bridge the gap. It was all inspired by Mandela. If he could do it, I could do it. You are talking about South Africa and the city of Boston, just a whole mess. Within two years’ time, and it took a couple of years, but I was able to find a group of Harvard-trained Black ministers who had moved into the inner city, into the neighborhoods, and had no relationships outside of their bubble.
They were really working with gangs on the streets. They were not the group that the traditional peacemakers, if you will, the Anti-Defamation League, were meeting with. They were the bigwigs, the big names. They would schmooze with the Cardinal or the head of the big Baptist church. These guys were unbelievably smart, but real grassroots and really wanted to work directly with gang members and see if they could turn this around.
I ended up just serendipitously, accidentally, through an interesting developing relationship and a real friendship that has lasted to this day with these three key Black ministers, each of whom was ministering to gangs, committed that I was going to figure out a way to get the largely Jewish suburban community that had once lived in great numbers in the city and been merchants to be engaged. I did not quite know how I was going to do this.
If we go back to Mandela being there, what was the moment?
The moment was that you can work across differences, no matter how big that gulf is, if you believe in the overarching goal of peace and prosperity and possibility, if you believe it is possible.
Did you get that from when he addressed you in this crowd of 10,000 people?
Yes, in all my readings and everything else, but it was the combination of his humanity, his grace, and his wisdom. It was this incredible mix of someone who had been in jail for 27 years. I remember thinking, “How is he even standing and speaking and wanting to continue to continue?” It just felt so inspiring, so inspiring. I said, “If he can do it, I certainly can do it in the city of Boston.”
That is a wonderful, inspirational moment, Nancy. Can you just take us through some of the key steps again? How did you pivot out of that situation in Boston? What actions did you take, and what was the outcome?
I am going to zero in on a particular incident that happened in the process, which was a stabbing in Morning Star Baptist Church. A Baptist church in the heart of the city, where a gang member was present during the funeral of another gang member in the city. The stabbing happens. It was right after the LA riot, so there was already this fear of, “What is going to happen? Is this going to erupt?” My Black minister friends made a call to clergy from all over Boston to come together and meet and open their doors to gang members.
I was called by a number of rabbis who said, “What do we do? There’s a call to the clergy.” Understand that at that time, I think there was one small congregation in the city of Jews, and it was not really in the inner city. The question is, “Do you show up? What do we do? What is the appropriate role for a white suburban Jewish rabbi who cares about what is happening but does not know what to do?” I did not know how to answer that question. I picked up the phone in the middle of all this, called one of my Black minister friends, and posed the question.
Do I tell them what we should do? I was not going to presume to know the answer. He said to me, I will never forget it, and this came up recently. Actually, he said to me, “Nancy, it’s a good question. I cannot think about it right now. Tell them to come. What I want you to do is, after this is done, will you pull together a group of rabbis and I’ll pull together a group of Black ministers, and let’s have the conversation about what is the appropriate role of the suburban Jewish community in the inner city?” That is what happened.
We met in the basement of a synagogue for about a year and a half. The moment that I most remember, the greatest learning and pivot that I do remember, was when one of the rabbis said to one of the Black ministers, “My congregation would love to come to help you in one of your parks, clean up the park,” because there were drugs and there were needles. My Black minister friend looked at him and said, “We don’t need you to clean up our park. We need jobs for our single female-headed households.”
That is when I had an epiphany, a moment when I said, “The Jewish community is doing more to help recently arrived immigrants from Russia with jobs and micro-enterprises. We do it through the Jewish Vocational Service. What if we were to do it for Black women?” I opposed it because it was like, “How do we do that?” I said, “Would that be helpful?” I went to the head of the organization, and she said, “We would need a partner.”
I went back, and the Black Ministerial Alliance became the partner, and we got the Department of Labor to give money that they were giving us for the Russian community to use for training single Black male-headed households. I was very proud of that moment, but it was definitely a ‘Mandela Moment.’ It was a moment of how to creatively approach a situation without the presumption that you know the answer. I did not know the answer.
We do not, don’t we?
We do not know the answer. As a community organizer, that is something I learned early on, which is that we have to meet people where they are at. That is the mistake we make too often, and when I say we, I mean whether it’s the white privileged community or Jewish community, whoever we’re talking about, is that we are so smart that we know the answer, as opposed to listening. That was followed by organizing Freedom Summer ’94 on the anniversary of Freedom Summer, where you mobilized White graduate students to go into the city and work with kids, again in partnership.
We have to meet people where they are. Too often, we make the mistake of thinking we already know the answer—whether in any community—rather than listening first.
Again, everyone was saying, “What are you talking about? What are you doing? How are we going to get there? What are we going to do?” I became a regular driver on the city’s streets. A little bit of Boston, but your audience probably does not know that you can live in Boston your whole life and never be in the inner city. You can drive from the airport to the suburbs, to Cambridge, to Brookline, to the suburbs, and never see the neighborhoods of the city. I used to make it my business to take tours. You never have to go through Roxbury, Dorchester, or Mattapan. You have to go over a bridge to do that, and there is no reason to go because that is not where the commercial district is.
You make a really important point, Nancy, because what really comes to mind is that from a leadership point of view, we need to get up close to these areas that we do not understand, that are in the middle of these problems we do not fully understand. What strikes me about what you are saying is just how important it is to immerse oneself in these communities, get up close, talk to people, and engage.
That is exactly right. This came back to me. I just remembered, as we were talking. When I went to South Africa and visited Soweto, walking the streets and meeting with some of the people and seeing the squalor, and yet seeing the leadership that was emerging, and that wanted to change. It could be the inner city neighborhoods of Boston or the townships in South Africa. You have to believe in the capacity of every person to make a difference, not where they happen to live. I saw the squalor and the poverty, and yet the rays of hope in light of people wanting to organize their community.
That is the paradox, isn’t it? It is an interesting paradox. Going back to your wonderful example of the inner city of Boston, getting the money to train these woman-headed households must have been a big moment. Was there a moment after that where you saw that effort, investment, and training come to fruition? How did you feel at that point in time?
Massive Organizing Effort Leads To Health Care For All
This became the gift that kept on giving because the more we dipped our toes in, the more the partnerships deepened and the more trust was built. I got synagogues engaged; we brought the entire Jewish community together, but ultimately it coalesced into The Greater Boston Interfaith Organization, a massive organizing effort. Again, that started as a predominantly Christian effort, and then we were the first group that joined as Jews.
There were times, fast forward, when we would be at a gathering, and I would be afraid there would be too many Jews there. Literally, you would have half the audience being Jewish, whether it was in the inner city or it was in the suburbs. I remember bringing the mayor of the city of Haifa, Israel, to one of these gatherings, and he was like, “If only I could do this in my city with Arabs and Jews together.” They all cheered.
We were able to get, and this is again, fast-forward by working together across all these different groups, to get healthcare for all passed in Massachusetts. I still call it Romneycare, even though when he was running for president, he did not like that, but it was really the precursor to Obamacare. We got it done in Massachusetts because all of this relationship-building converged into a huge effort to help get Romneycare approved in Massachusetts as the first state in the nation.
Fast forward, I am curious to hear the end of the story for these women.
Some developed micro-enterprise businesses on their own, and others got jobs. It was magnificent. The program became a model, grew, and helped all kinds of different ethnic and racial groups as we went along. It was planting a seed and developing partnerships that are now old news. The community is very enmeshed in the general community in Massachusetts. In fact, I just heard that my former organization is spearheading an effort with the Catholic community and other faith communities to resettle Afghan refugees.
This really has become a way of being. This transition has changed how these organizations function and the extent to which the Jewish community invests in interfaith projects and initiatives.
It was not that way. It really was not that way. That is real.
How do you feel, Nancy?
I feel great. I feel very proud of the work that I did there, and that it has continued and sustained. It is a wonderful feeling.
I guess you have just picked up one point, which does come to mind. What were the key points that ensured it sustained? Often we see these initiatives, but they do not have the sustainability, they do not have the legs. What created sustainability? Just in key summary points.
I really believe, and it goes to some of your definitions of leadership, that the whole issue of social leadership and practical leadership, but building bridges, influencing, and energizing others, is what we talked about. When you build relationships that are authentic and not just based on what you need at the time, but are based on what others need as well, and it is mutual, incredible things can happen. There are many variations to this story. I could go on about some of the things that we did for each other in terms of these relationships.
Can you just share one example with us?
I will share one example. It is actually two parts. One is when one of my Black minister friends. The situation in the city had gotten so bad that he felt he needed to move for the sake of his children. He actually needed to move, and he knew that the press was going to destroy him for this. I was able to work behind the scenes to get a positive rather than a negative story because he was not leaving his pulpit. It was a very tough time.
Can you just elaborate on why the press was going to crucify him?
Just as he was moving out of the city. It was a credibility issue. The same person flipped the switch as a Presbyterian minister. When the Presbyterians were thinking about divesting from Israel, and I do think the Israel situation is a very different situation than South Africa, albeit a very challenging one, he was about to be the speaker at my annual meeting, and there was no quid pro quo; there was nothing, but I spoke to him. He was going to be talking about healthcare and the work we had done together, and I told him about the situation, and he wanted more information.
He did not know much about it. He did not know that this was happening. After studying it and talking to people, he decided, as a Presbyterian African-American minister, to denounce the Presbyterian divestment from Israel publicly. I did not ask him to do that, I did not say that you can only be a speaker if you do that, but it was huge. I ended up taking him and a group of his colleagues, other African-American clergy, and Christian clergy, to Israel to engage there with both Palestinians and Israelis to really try to understand that conflict.
What have been the key leadership lessons, given the incredible journey you have traveled, that for you are so relevant in the Middle East today? I know that is a huge question, but are there like 2 or 3 big leadership lessons that you think can help navigate this current ongoing, multi-decade-long conflict?
I have actually spent an enormous amount of time on this since I first came into the Jewish community in 1990. Quite frankly, I had not been to Israel for 24 years, not having been brought up in the ideological wars of Israel, I adopted early on. We have to support the democratically elected government of Israel because that was the party line. I have evolved considerably since then to now, feeling like if we can criticize our government here in the United States and be proud citizens, we can criticize the government of Israel when we do not think they are doing the right thing, that is number one.
Leaders Must Criticize Israel’s Government: Speak Up For A Two-State Solution
Two, in back rooms for years, leaders in the Jewish community of all stripes would talk about how terrible the settlements were. They would say it, but not publicly. They would not take a position because they were afraid that they would be accused of being anti-Israel. I now feel that I, and I do it regularly now, feel we must, as leaders, say that we love Israel, we support Israel, we want to see a Jewish democratic state, but we also believe there needs to be a state for the Palestinian people, and we cannot rule over other people.
We want to see a Jewish democratic state, but also a Palestinian state. No one should rule over another.
If Israel wants to remain a Jewish democratic space, they have to decide what they are going to do. Either they are going to be a Jewish state or a democratic state. If they want to give up one, it is one thing, which I do not think they do. If they want to be both, there is only one option: two states for two people. If the situation as it is now remains, they will cease to be democratic because they will be ruling over other people who do not have citizen rights, or it will be one state, and it will no longer be a Jewish state, just the demographics as such.
I have great clarity about this now. I have been speaking to a lot of progressive young people and to non-progressives. I really feel like I proudly can stand up and say, “I am a progressive pro-Israel feminist Zionist who cares about the rights of Palestinians.” If more of us could do that, I think we could really make a difference. One of the great moments for me was a few years ago, when I traveled to the West Bank with a program called Encounter for Jewish leaders in the United States. I have gone a couple of times now, and it has been a total eye-opener.
It was basically that we were there to meet with real people on the ground who are trying to live their lives. It was a really forceful experience because, again, if you talk to people, and I am not talking about political leaders, and I am not talking about rhetoric, I am talking about people who want the same thing for their children that each of us wants for ours. If you, again, in my case, Jewish values, but whatever value system you operate from, then you want to do something about it.
You want to do something about the women I met in an Arab village who had organized solar panels and had them destroyed by the army because they did not have a permit. They filed a lawsuit and actually won after years, and they had to put the solar panels back. These are inspirational Mandela Moments, if you will, all the time; they are real people, ordinary people doing extraordinary things every day. My feeling is, you know, I cannot give up hope, although many people caught up in the conflict are giving up hope. It is going to take real people, the people of Israel, the people of Palestine, not their leaders necessarily, but the grassroots saying, “Enough, enough. We want a future.”
A future that has a place at the table for everybody. You raised an important point about feeling comfortable in criticizing the government. I just wanted you to expand a little about when we criticize, what are your thoughts around how we should criticize? Very often, it is very easy for people to have a finger facing forward, but quite often they have three fingers facing backward. What is important for you in critiquing whoever we are criticizing?
I am a big believer in process and respect for authority, and I try to at least begin by having the conversation, organizing it, and starting it privately so that you are not embarrassing anyone or putting anyone in a spot. If that is necessary, you can do it publicly. I remember at one point a major Jewish leader said to me, “I’ve organized all my donors, and they’re very upset about the settlements. We met with the local Consul General in Boston.” I said, “That’s great, and when are you getting on a plane to go meet with Netanyahu to tell them that’s how you feel?” In other words, we have power, and the question is, “How do you exercise that power?”
What was his response?
He just rolled his eyes as if to say, “Are you kidding me?” In other words, he wanted to brag about this local meeting, but he was not really willing to take the next step.
What is the message for leaders, Nancy? That is an interesting illustration where people feel strongly about things, and there is a platform, they have a platform, but do they really step up and speak out? What is the lesson?
It is when we have these factional arguments, when, in my case, members of my community said, “We cannot go into the inner city. They do not want us there.” I remember saying at one point, “Let’s find the people who do want us there.” In other words, that is just baloney. It is not every person. I think we have to find allies, build those bridges, and really try to be practical and street-smart.
I want to pivot a little and come back to South Africa, the country of my birth and upbringing. I know you had a very special trip to South Africa. Could you take us to a Mandela Moment that really stands out for you in South Africa? Just set the setting for us. Where were you?
I had so many Mandela Moments when I was in South Africa, starting in Johannesburg, at the prison where we began. The most impactful Mandela Moment was, first of all, that we got to go to Robben Island because you do not always get to go, you know, the weather there.
That’s weather-dependent, yeah.
Robben Island Reinforced The Need For Patience And Staying The Course
It was a gorgeous day. We could not go to Table Mountain, but we went to Robben Island. I will just never forget standing at his cell and thinking, this man spent 27 years oppressed by his oppressors in prison, had every reason to be bitter and angry and resentful and revengeful, and came out of that situation and decided he wanted to change the world, change his country for the better, and work with those who had imprisoned him, which is what I found the most incredible. I have mentioned this to you, but I took his autobiography with me on this trip and read it from beginning to end. I kind of felt he was whispering in my ear the whole time. I felt like I literally had just read the section about prison, and there I was. It was remarkable.
When did you go, Nancy?
It was just 2019.
You had him on the journey with you.
He was on the journey with me. I absolutely had him on the journey with me. I took the whole book, started it on the plane going, and finished the last page on the plane returning. There was something. I felt like he was with me, and I felt like what he has done for the world, we need more Mandelas, and we have some, and as you know, because you’re interviewing many of them. What he did was to say that anything is possible. If he can overcome what he overcame and lead a nation forward. To me, it was remarkable.
Was that your a-ha moment in his prison?
Yes, it was my aha moment. It really was my a-ha moment. It was like he wrote, he talked, he followed the rules. It is just remarkable.
When you say he followed the rules.
He followed the rules. In other words, he did not try to escape from prison. His oppressors became involved in a relationship with him. That was the most unbelievable thing. He did not see them as the enemy. He saw them, in some ways, equally impacted and oppressed.
If he were at the UN, what do you think he would say?
He would say what he always said, which is that we need to work together. We need to come together. The world’s problems are so much bigger than any one of us. We can do it. We can solve them no matter how huge they are, and they are huge. It takes a real commitment and a real belief in the art of the possible, that it is possible, that it is possible to create change, and that leadership is really critical. I will say, just as a woman leader, that the more of us there are going forward, the happier I will be.
It takes real commitment and a belief in the art of the possible—the belief that change is possible, and that it is worth pursuing.
He would probably be very pleased that women are now finally taking their place in the universe. What he would say at the UN would be upbeat and positive, despite the fact that we live in a very challenging world. It needs great repair. In the Jewish community, we talk about repairing the world, Tikkun Olam, and we believe we have a partnership with God to do so; it’s our covenant.
What do you think Mandela would say to our youth? Yes, he loved women. His mother, he always said, was his first female best friend. He had great respect for women and loved them. The rights and role of women were very carefully crafted into South Africa’s constitution in 1996. Yes, he definitely was very pro-woman. Just very inclusive on every level. Equally, he loved children, and he really missed them. I’m just wondering, Nancy, what do you think Mandela would say to our youth of today?
He would say, “You can make a difference. You are the hope of the future. You must be engaged. Do not disengage. Do not be apathetic. Pick your issue and work for it. You do not have to do it all, but you need to do something.” It would inspire the youth. I see incredible examples of youth in my community, just unbelievable examples of incredible commitment, energy, and belief that we can change the world. It really makes me very happy because I see so many people giving up. He would be inspiring to the youth that they can change the world, that it only takes one person, and that they can change the world.
I would love to meet some of those youth members you talk about, too, someday, Nancy. I would love to hear about that. On a lighter note, you have traveled a lot. What has been your favorite city in the world?
Tel Aviv is definitely my favorite city in the world. It’s because it’s vibrant, beautiful, diverse, and has great food. I would say Cape Town is probably a second favorite. I love Cape Town. I just need to go back and spend more time there. Gorgeous and wonderful, and I love the people. I only spent a few days there, but I would like to spend more time.
Was it the people? What was it about it?
It is always the people, the passion of the people, the friendliness of the people. Wherever I go in the world, that is what it is. Those are two of my favorites.
You mentioned the food in Tel Aviv. By the way, I almost got there for the International Women’s Forum Conference, I think it was 2015, but that did not work out. It is on my list. I am so looking forward to visiting Tel Aviv. You mentioned the food. What has been your favorite meal to date, and what was it?
In Israel?
Generally, anywhere.
That is really a hard one.
Just a fantastic meal that comes to mind.
There are these unbelievable restaurants in Tel Aviv now. It probably was lamb in Tel Aviv, prepared in a Middle Eastern style. It was phenomenal.
That sounds great. Before we just close off, Nancy, leading boldly into the future. The world is calling out for bold leadership, and of course, we are at a global pivotal tipping point. What are the final takeaways you would like to share with people about leading boldly into the future?
Number one, patience and willingness to stay the course. We live in a culture of instant gratification. We expect change to be instant, and it is not. It takes a long time to create real lasting change, and you have to be in it for the long haul. You have to be in it for the long haul, or it is not going to happen. That is number one, and not measuring success by how quickly the change happens, but measuring it by the quality of the change, and that it is sustainable.
We live in a culture of instant gratification and expect change to happen quickly—but it doesn’t. Real, lasting change takes time, and you have to be in it for the long haul.
Having been part of the women’s movement, the LGBTQ movement, and now the racial justice movement, I just see enormous possibilities for change. There are setbacks, and we have had many of them, sadly, in this country in the last couple of years, particularly around voting rights, which is horribly troubling, but we cannot give up. We just cannot give up, because when we do, we cede it to the other side. If we really believe we are right, we need to put the energy into making change happen.
For those bold leaders, Nancy, who face those kinds of tipping points, those defining moments where you need that fortified moral courage, what would be your takeaway for them?
A couple of things. One of the things I have learned in my later life is self-care. We cannot be martyrs and work 24/7 and think that we are going to be effective. Whether it is meditation or exercise or healthy eating or all the above, I think there is much more commitment now to that than there ever was when I started out. Finding a coach, getting coaching, realizing that we do not have all the answers, and having support are helpful. We need to feed the leaders.
We need to understand that being a bold leader is not sustainable without an incredible network of support and good health. That is really critical. I am seeing a change in that regard, too, a big change in the Jewish community and in the general community. We have all these corporations working with mindfulness. People are realizing that the old models just are not working anymore. Those are important pieces of it.
Nancy, you’re a blessing. I hope to get to Tel Aviv with you one day.
I would love that.
I could not think of a better person to travel to that part of the world with. Just thank you for your goodness, your kindness, your greatness, and thank you for sharing your insights with us.
Thank you, Anne, and thank you for keeping Mandela’s memory alive and in everyone’s consciousness. This is wonderful. Thank you so much. Great to talk to you.
—
LEADERSHIP WRAP
Friends, we are wired for speed, but time is a weapon, so stay the course and mobilize the system. In the West, we prize fast action, decisive moves, and quick wins. But my good friend, Nancy Kaufman, an Executive Coach, the former Executive Director of the Boston Jewish Community Relations Council, a four-time recipient of the Forward 50 Outstanding Jewish Leader Award, former CEO of the National Council of Jewish Women, and a Harvard Kennedy School adaptive leadership friend and fellow scholar, challenges us to rethink how we exercise leadership playing the long game, using time as a weapon, and mobilizing the system. Post 9/11 in the early 2000s, two large commercial jets flew straight into the Twin Towers in New York City.
The world declared war on terror. Islamophobia and fear were weaponized. Back in Boston, where Nancy lived and worked at the time, wealthy Jewish donors of her Boston Jewish Community Relations Council called on her to stop the building of a Muslim mosque. Instead, around seven years later, she gave the closing prayer inside it.
There are seven key ways in which Nancy reveals how we can use the weapon of time and mobilize the system.
1. Do a reality check before “taking action.”
Fear-based assumptions are not facts. Nancy challenged the narrative, paused, and reframed the default anti-Semitic interpretation.
2. Find your allies in unexpected places.
She called on Deans at Harvard and the Kennedy School, the Divinity School, senior leaders in the Jewish community, and the head of the Anti-Defamation League. Quietly, she built a powerful coalition of unexpected allies that people did not see coming.
3. Regulate the heat.
Do not extinguish it. Leaders of excellence don’t kill the conflict. They orchestrate it. She created a steady holding environment, a safe space for heated debate, both inside the Jewish community and across the broader interfaith community.
4. Speak the unspeakable.
Nancy spoke the truth and challenged false narratives, even when it put her credibility and job on the line. She proudly declared she would speak the truth under oath in pending court cases.
5. Build a force against the force.
When she could not speak up publicly, others spoke up with equal power and conviction.
6. Give the work back.
Creating shared responsibility for the future builds resilient communities. She did not carry it alone. She developed leadership capacity not only within the Jewish community but also across her interfaith communities.
7. Hold the faith. The impossible is possible, and time is a weapon.
Nancy did not stop the building of the mosque. Instead, seven years on, she gave the closing prayer inside it. More than 1,000 worshippers cheered, clapped, and celebrated as this bold Jewish woman, guided by her Jewish values, belted out of Isaiah 58. “Free the Oppressed, House the Homeless, Loosen the Bonds of Wickedness.” Within seven years, seven years on, Muslims, Jews, and Christians were all free.
Here’s the twist that is seldom recorded. The very person within her own Jewish community who fought hardest against her within a decade, funded the very organization she once led. In the West, we are taught to act quickly to achieve completion. One of Nancy Kaufman’s greatest acts of leadership was using time as a weapon, staying the course, and mobilizing the system with truth, patience, and courage and conviction on her side.
While the current conflicts in the Middle East rage on, the unresolved history and the impact of heightened competition for religious legitimacy, political power, and dominant hegemony between Christians, Muslims, and Jews patiently await real leadership, adaptive leadership, and resolution.
Fear never wins. Truth, patience, courage, and conviction bend the arc of change. Time is a weapon, and Nancy knew exactly how to wield it. Perhaps the leaders of the world and the leaders in the Middle East will take a page out of Nancy’s book to find joyful resolution and lasting peace.
Until next time, remember that leading boldly is about making these thoughtful, clear choices. Bold leadership is about taking bold action, just one small step at a time, one step for you. Together, with time as a weapon, when we mobilize the system, a giant step for humanity. Take care and take thoughtful, bold action.
Important Links
- Nancy Kaufman
- Nancy Kaufman on LinkedIn
- Nancy Kaufman on X
- Nancy Kaufman on Facebook
- Nancy Kaufman on Instagram
- Special Message from Nancy K. Kaufman on YouTube
About Nancy Kaufman
Nancy K. Kaufman has had a distinguished career as a public servant, advocate, and non-profit leader. Kaufman now runs a strategic consulting and coaching practice, having stepped down as CEO of the National Council of Jewish Women (NCJW), where she served for eight years, beginning in January 2011. At NCJW, she reenergized this 125-year-old legacy organization of volunteers and advocates that turn progressive ideals into action and advance social and economic justice for women, children, and families.
Prior to joining NCJW, Kaufman served as the executive director of the Jewish Community Relations Council (JCRC) of Boston for twenty years until December 2010, where she led the social justice, Israel advocacy, and governmental affairs agendas for Boston’s Jewish Federation and its agencies. She has also held a variety of positions related to health and human services delivery in state and local government and in the nonprofit sector. She worked for the Commonwealth of Massachusetts as Deputy Director of the Governor’s Social Policy Office, Assistant Secretary of Health and Human Services, and Deputy Commissioner of the Welfare Department. At age 27, she was the founding executive director of a community action agency north of Boston.
Kaufman is a graduate of Brandeis University, received an MSW in community organization and social planning from Boston College School of Social Work, and a mid-career MPA from the Kennedy School of Government at Harvard University. Among other honors, she is a recipient of an honorary doctorate in public service from Northeastern University; the Alumni Achievement Award (1987) and the Bernard Reisman Award for professional excellence (2011) from Brandeis University; and the Albert C. Chernin Award from the Jewish Council for Public Affairs (2019). She was recognized four times as a “Forward 50” outstanding Jewish leader.
Kaufman was a founding board member of the Jewish Organizing Initiative (now JOIN for Justice), the Jewish Social Justice Roundtable, and the Safety/Respect/Equity Network. Kaufman has a certificate in executive coaching from Presence-Based Coaching and is an ICF-accredited coach. She is part of the CFAR Coaching Network and is a coach for the SPERTUS, ELLUMINATE, and Wexner Leadership Programs. She is an active member of the Adaptive Leadership Network and currently serves as board chair of the NY Jewish Agenda. She is also a board member of the Alliance for Middle East Peace (ALLMEP). In January 2022, she was appointed by President Biden to the Commission on the Preservation of American Heritage Abroad.